A roof replacement is the largest single repair most people make to a house, and the quotes you collect for it are usually impossible to compare — because most of them are one number. Ours is not. You get tear-off, decking allowance, ice-and-water shield, synthetic underlayment, starter course, shingles, ridge cap, drip edge, all new flashing, ventilation, dumpster and disposal, and the permit, each priced separately. When another contractor's total comes in lower, you can see exactly which line they left out. Nine times out of ten around here it is the decking allowance or the flashing.
The code baseline matters more in Massachusetts than in most states, because our failure mode is ice. 780 CMR requires an ice barrier membrane running from the eave edge to a point at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line, and it caps asphalt roofs at two layers. On shallow pitches between 2:12 and 4:12 it additionally requires doubled underlayment across the whole field, which is why a low rear addition costs more per square foot than the main roof. If your house already carries two layers, a third is not an option and the tear-off is not negotiable. This is the single most common reason a cheap quote turns into a mid-job price change, so we establish the layer count during the inspection, not on tear-off morning.
Ventilation is the part homeowners skip and manufacturers quietly rely on. Nearly every shingle warranty in the industry is conditional on adequate intake and exhaust ventilation, and a great many attics in these towns have exhaust at the ridge with the soffit intake blocked by insulation shoved into the eaves decades ago. The result is a hot attic in July, a snow-melting attic in January and shingles that age out five to eight years early. We measure the net free vent area, open the intake and install continuous ridge venting as part of the job rather than as an optional line at the end.
The practical questions — how long, how messy, what happens to the garden — have honest answers. Most single-family roofs in these towns are a one or two day tear-off and install once materials are on site. We tarp planting beds, set the dumpster where it will not crack a driveway apron, pull gutters where they would be damaged, and run a magnet over the lawn and drive at the end of each day. We do not tear off more roof than we can dry in before the weather turns, which occasionally means a slower schedule and never means a wet ceiling.
Technician insight
The line that decides whether a quote is honest is the decking allowance. Every roof in this area that is thirty years old has some soft sheathing somewhere, usually at the north eave or around a chimney. A quote with no allowance is not cheaper — it just moves that conversation to the day your roof is open and you have no leverage.
Two layers found before signing, not after
A 1978 colonial in Littleton had two layers of shingles and a quote from elsewhere that assumed one. Our inspection found the second layer at the rake edge before anything was signed, along with four sheets of soft decking at the north eave where an ice dam had been running for years. The quote carried the second-layer removal and an eight-sheet allowance; six sheets were used and the two unused were credited back off the final invoice.
Roof Replacement Services We Offer
✓Full Tear-Off to the Deck
Complete removal of existing shingles and underlayment down to the bare deck, including second layers, with the sheathing inspected sheet by sheet as it is exposed.
✓Ice Barrier and Underlayment
Ice-and-water shield at eaves, valleys and around every penetration, run to the depth 780 CMR requires for this climate zone, with synthetic underlayment over the field.
✓Architectural Shingle Installation
Architectural asphalt shingles in standard and impact-resistant grades, with material and wind-rating options explained against what your exposure actually needs.
✓Complete Flashing Replacement
New drip edge, valley metal, step and counter flashing, and chimney work — all replaced rather than reused, which is where reused metal quietly ends a new roof early.
✓Attic Ventilation Correction
Soffit intake opened and baffled, continuous ridge vent installed, and bath or kitchen fans redirected out through the roof instead of into the attic.
✓Roof Deck Replacement
Rotted or delaminated sheathing replaced sheet by sheet against an allowance quoted up front, so discovered rot is a known cost rather than a surprise invoice.
Roof Replacement Cost in Boxborough, MA
| Service | Typical Range | What Affects It |
|---|---|---|
| Architectural asphalt, installed | $450–$750 | Per square, including tear-off of one layer |
| Second layer removal | $50–$90 | Additional, per square |
| Decking allowance | $120–$220 | Per 4x8 sheet — unused sheets credited back |
| Impact-resistant (Class 4) shingles | +$90–$180/sq | Upgrade — check whether your carrier discounts these |
| Ridge and soffit ventilation | $600–$1,800 | Continuous ridge vent and intake correction |
| Building permit | At cost | Charged at cost — each town sets its own rate |
Ranges are typical for Boxborough, MA and confirmed with an exact written quote before any work starts.
How it works
- 1
Measure, count layers, inspect the attic
We measure the roof properly, count the existing layers, check the pitch and the complexity, and go into the attic to look at ventilation, insulation depth at the eaves and the condition of the deck from underneath.
- 2
Itemised quote with options priced separately
You get the quote broken into line items with a decking allowance stated as a per-sheet rate and an assumed quantity, so you know both the base price and what rot would cost if we find it. Material options are priced side by side rather than presented as one take-it-or-leave-it package.
- 3
Permit filed, install scheduled to the weather
We file the building permit with your town — Boxborough through the PermitPro portal, the surrounding towns through their own building departments — and book the install around a dry weather window. Material delivery is timed so the load is not sitting on your drive for a week.
- 4
Protect the property, tear off in stages
Beds and shrubs get tarped, the dumpster is placed on protection, and gutters come off where they would be damaged. Tear-off is done in sections we can dry in the same day, and every exposed sheet of decking is checked underfoot before anything covers it.
- 5
Install, inspect, clean and walk it with you
Ice-and-water shield, underlayment, drip edge, starter, field shingles, new flashing at every penetration, ridge venting and ridge cap. Then a full cleanup, a magnet sweep, the town inspection, and a walkthrough with the photographs of what was underneath.
Pricing
Architectural asphalt generally runs about $450 to $750 per square (100 square feet of roof area, not floor area) installed with tear-off. What that comes to depends mostly on the house: a single-storey ranch or split-level typically lands around $10,000 to $16,000, and a two-storey colonial around $14,000 to $22,000. Steep pitch, multiple dormers and valleys, a second layer to remove, or significant deck rot push those figures up; impact-resistant and metal systems sit above them. Only an on-site measurement produces a number worth signing.